A Peaceful Stay with Great Coffee – but a Little Far from Most Places
Sep 24, 2026
We stayed at La Casa Sul Faro during our visit to Procida and overall had a very pleasant stay. The property is located in a very quiet part of the island, surrounded by a garden. The biggest advantage of the hotel is definitely the peace and quiet.
We arrived by ferry from Naples and walked from the port to the hotel, which took us about 25 minutes. The walk is uphill in places, but this was not a problem for us, as we actually explored the entire island on foot during our stay. The hotel was easy to find using Google Maps. The location is a little far from most places, however. The nearest bus stop is about five minutes away, a small supermarket is around 10 minutes on foot, and there are some restaurants relatively close by, although most are further away. The nearest beaches are roughly 15–25 minutes away. For people who do not enjoy walking, I would recommend renting a bicycle or, even better, a scooter. A car is probably less convenient because of Procida’s narrow streets.
Check-in itself was easy once Vincenzo arrived. He was very friendly, helpful and easy to communicate with, and his English was actually perfectly fine despite his claims otherwise. One useful tip for future guests is that if nobody is immediately at reception, it is worth walking around the property, as the staff may simply be helping other guests elsewhere.
We stayed in room 202, a standard double room on the first floor. The room was a reasonable size – not particularly large, but certainly not cramped – and our actual room looked even better than in the Booking.com photos. There was enough storage space for our backpacks, although guests travelling with large suitcases might find it less convenient. The bed was comfortable and we slept well. Each person had two pillows, with an additional pillow and extra blankets available in the wardrobe. The external shutters were also great for making the room completely dark at night.
The view from our room was partly towards the historic centre and partly towards the sea. It was generally quiet at night, although the sound insulation was not particularly strong, so loud guests in the corridor or neighbouring rooms could easily be heard. Fortunately, we had quiet neighbours. The air conditioning worked well, although it frequently made some strange noises. They were not noticeable when wearing earplugs, though.
The room had a minibar and TV, but there was no safe or kettle, neither of which we really needed. There were also no proper glasses or cups – only small plastic cups, two in the bathroom and two in the room, which felt rather basic. Apart from that, we did not experience any problems with the room equipment.
The bathroom was one of the highlights. It was surprisingly large, very clean and well maintained, with a spacious shower and a bidet. We had no problems with the water temperature, water pressure or drainage. There were plenty of towels, with at least three towels per person. Overall, the cleanliness of both the room and bathroom was excellent.
The property itself is clean and peaceful, but we felt that it does not quite live up to its full potential. Many reviews describe La Casa Sul Faro as an “oasis of peace”, and the peaceful atmosphere is absolutely true, but we felt that the property itself could make better use of its potential. The promotional photos also showed bicycles and sun loungers with parasols, but we did not see bicycles available for guests to rent, while the sun loungers appeared to be stored away and looked as though they had not been used for quite some time. The garden was pleasant but felt somewhat underused.
At the back there is a large pergola where breakfast is served and where guests can relax or have something to eat. There is also a bar, although the restaurant that apparently used to operate there is now closed. The pergola is a nice place to sit and have a drink or coffee, although we did encounter some wasps there and there were ants around. The ants did not really bother us, although the wasps were more noticeable.
Breakfast was good and served as a buffet under the large pergola. There was a choice of both sweet and savoury food, and the overall quality was good. The selection was decent, but the buffet could struggle when several guests arrived at the same time. If there were, for example, only three cornetti and four people suddenly arrived, they disappeared rather quickly. The staff did replenish the food, but sometimes it simply disappeared faster than it could be replaced. I also missed having eggs available.
Coffee, however, deserves a special mention. You could choose whichever type of coffee you wanted and it was brought to your table. The espresso was honestly the best espresso I have ever had at an accommodation. That was definitely one of the highlights of breakfast.
The staff were generally very friendly, kind and helpful. Communication was sometimes easier in Italian than English, but once I started speaking Italian, everything was absolutely fine.
We also appreciated being able to leave our luggage at the property after check-out, go to the beach, return later and take a shower before leaving. This was a very useful extra service.
One thing worth mentioning is that the rooms on the ground floor with terraces may not necessarily be our first choice. The terraces are positioned along the route from the entrance towards the upper floors, the pergola and the bar, so guests sitting there have relatively little privacy. Personally, I would prefer a room upstairs like ours.
Overall, La Casa Sul Faro is a peaceful and pleasant place to stay, particularly if you value tranquillity and want somewhere away from the busier parts of Procida. The biggest downside is the location – it is somewhat removed from most of the island’s main areas. For us, this was not a major problem because we enjoy walking and managed to explore the entire island on foot, but for other guests I would recommend renting a scooter or bicycle.
We would definitely stay here again. I would particularly recommend La Casa Sul Faro to couples looking for a peaceful or romantic stay. It is definitely not a place for party travellers, while families with young children might find the distance to the beaches and other parts of the island less convenient.
Highly recommended
Aug 25, 2026
Highly recommended... Very warm welcome under a spectacular lemon arbor; Giovanni and his father are two very kind people and very attentive to details. Breakfast, under the arbor, was very abundant, and Giovanni and his father provided us with very good, quality products; we requested a vegan breakfast and they provided us with fresh bread, jams, cookies, yogurt, juices, soy cappuccino, and a very delicious little ricotta made with almond milk, truly excellent. Furthermore, they recommended where we could have dinner, and I must say that we always found excellent places. Thanks for everything, Enrico and Nadia
Perfect experience!
Jun 17, 2026
Although we arrived late and breakfast time had already passed, we were welcomed with an old-fashioned kindness. We were offered a splendid breakfast (absolutely not required given the time!) just for the pleasure of letting us taste the delicious homemade pastries prepared by Giovanni's mother, accompanied by exquisite coffee. A business card that immediately conveys the heart and passion that the owners put into hospitality.
The room is spacious, exceptionally clean, and equipped with all the necessary comforts for a completely relaxing stay.
The place is literally enchanting. Waking up in the morning surrounded by greenery, pampered only by the singing of the birds, is a rejuvenating experience.
The true highlight of the establishment is the fantastic lemon grove, a true oasis of peace where one can have breakfast immersed in the scents and colors of nature.
5-star hospitality
A special thanks goes to Giovanni and his father. Two exquisite individuals, always incredibly available and ready to provide us with the best advice and information to fully enjoy the island, including excellent tips on restaurants where to eat.